Posted by
Playful Walrus on Monday, September 07, 2009 4:00:00 PM
Here is a simple set of questions you can ask people who tell you we need Obamacare, or more federal funding/control of health care and health insurance.
Do you personally...
1. Expect to pay for the care of other people you don't know in addition to your own (net financial/service loss on your part, gain on their part);
2. Expect other people who don't know you to pay for your care in addition to their own (net financial/service gain on your part, loss on their part);
3. Expect that by pooling money with other people, you will come out about even with them in the long run;
4. Expect medical professionals and those involved in constructing/operating/maintaining medical facilities and equipment to work for free (net financial/service loss on their part, gain on your part)?
Few of them will honestly say #1. If they do, ask them what is stopping them from doing this right now, by donating to/volunteering for medical charities? Obamacare is not needed for this.
Most are secretly hoping for #2, but might be embarrassed to admit it, and they should be.
Most will claim option #3. Again, there's nothing stopping them from doing this now. They can go to their neighbor right now and come up with an agreement to share medical costs.
They will point to other countries when you bring up #4, saying that these people get paid in other countries. Yes, but have you noticed how many of these people in other countries come to the USA? Why is that?
The fact of the matter is, due to administration, any insurance means that the average person will have somewhat of a loss, no matter how minor. That is the cost of administration of insurance. Why would the federal government be any better at administrating than a voluntarily-joined insurance company/cooperative/nonprofit?
Unfortunately, people are quick to turn to the federal government to solve what they perceive to be problems. They want Obama to make their lives better. But there are other options. There are state governments, local governments, special districts... better yet there are individual choices and initiatives, businesses, nonprofits, and cooperatives.
Why should I be forced, under threat of imprisonment, to pay for someone else's health care?